Archaeological Investigation in Hokkaido by Kazuchika Komai: Excavation Photographs Digital Archives

1 Archaeological investigation in Hokkaido by Kazuchika Komai: from excavation of Moyoro Shell Mound to beginning of investigation at Tokoro

(1) From mainland China to Hokkaido

Kazuchika Komai became a research associate in the Faculty of Letters at Tokyo Imperial University in 1927 and participated in the Far Eastern Archaeological Society, an academic society established that year, mainly by professors at Kyoto Imperial University and Tokyo Imperial University, in order to promote archaeological investigations in East Asia. As oriental archaeologists, Komai and Yoshito Harada, the first professor of the course of Archaeology at Tokyo Imperial University and an active participant in the Far Eastern Archaeological Society, promoted archaeological investigations in China and Korea.

After World War Ⅱ, the Far Eastern Archaeological Society carried out an excavation of the Toro Site at Shizuoka City and the Moyoro Shell Mound at Abashiri City in 1947. Komai became an associate professor at the Department of Archaeology of the Faculty of Letters, established in the preceding year, and he played an active role in the excavation of these archaeological sites.

It is understood that, after World War Ⅱ, Seiichi Mizuno at Kyoto University and Komai decided that Kyoto University would focus on Iki and Tsushima in Kyusyu and that the University of Tokyo would focus on Hokkaido (Sugimura 1977). This was because they wanted to clarify the relationship between continental Eurasia and Japan in the western and eastern regions, the contact point between the Asian continent and the islands of Japan (Onuki 2002). After the investigation in the Moyoro Shell Mound, Komai decided on Hokkaido as a new site for his archaeological studies. Thereafter, he promoted research into clarifying the history of the Ainu through archaeological methods and materials, which he called “Ainu Archaeology.”

(2) Investigation of stone circles and shell mounds

Alongside the Moyoro Shell Mound, Komai focused on the stone circles of the Jomon period (1) and on the shell mounds from the Jomon and Epi-Jomon periods. Komai pointed out that the potteries and bronze artifacts of the Okhotsk culture have features of the Asian continent. He also examined the stone circles in Hokkaido because of their similarity to the megalithic monuments that are widely distributed in Europe and Asia, especially Siberia. In addition, before the war, Komai had investigated the stone circle in the south of Hyrule, located in the northwest part of Manchuria (the Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, today part of China), and he had confirmed that it was a kind of tomb, so he wanted to clarify the characteristics of the stone circles in Hokkaido. He therefore began to excavate the Jichin’yama Stone Circle in Yoichi Town in 1949 and undertook the excavations of the stone circles in Hokkaido until 1956.

Komai did not clearly explain the motivation for the investigation of shell mounds, but according to Shizuo Onuki (Onuki 2002), these investigations were carried out in order to find human bones and study them anthropologically. Many human bones were excavated in the Moyoro Shell Mound. Komai heard the results of the morphological study and believed that the Okhotsk people assimilated into the Ainu after migrating from outside Hokkaido. It seems that this study gave Komai the motivation to carry out the study of shell mounds and human bones. After that, Komai began his investigations in Hokkaido in order to answer three questions: “When did the ancestors of Ainu start living in Hokkaido, and where did they come from and where did they settle down?” (Komai 1973:138).

It was 1949 when Komai excavated the Higashi Kushiro Shell Mound from the Jomon period at Kushiro City, next to the excavation of the Moyoro Shell Mound (Komai 1952, Kono and Sawa 1962). However, there are no records of the chronological table (Komai [Fujie ed.] 1977) for this excavation, and no detailed investigation reports have been published. Komai also observed some chashi sites around the Higashi Kushiro Shell Mound and took photographs at the time.

Komai also carried out the excavation of the Ojironai Shell Mound from the Epi-Jomon period at Mori Town. This excavation was started in 1951 and continued until 1953, with a supplementary investigation being conducted in 1958.

Furthermore, in addition to the excavation of the stone circles and shell mounds, in 1951 Komai also carried out a general survey at Utoro, Rausu, and its surroundings while based in Abashiri (Komai 1964: 99). This general survey later led to an excavation at the Shiretoko Peninsula.

(3) Encounter of Komai and Tokoro Town

The next turning point in Komai's investigation in Hokkaido was the encounter with Tokoro Town (Kitami City today). It was Shiro Hattori and Nobutake Onishi who led the encounter. Hattori was a professor at the Faculty of Letters of the University of Tokyo who visited Tokoro Town to conduct research into the Sakhalin Ainu language. Onishi was a local person who argued for the importance of the archaeological sites in Tokoro Town.

Hattori started a linguistic survey of the Sakhalin Ainu language in Tokoro Town in 1955 and encountered Onishi there. When Hattori visited Tokoro Town again the following year, Onishi asked him to invite archaeologists from the University of Tokyo. Komai heard this from Hattori, visited Tokoro Town, viewed the archaeological sites in Tokoro with Onishi in the fall of that year, and decided to carry out an excavation. Komai wrote that it was because he had “come up with the idea of investigating the archaeological sites, such as the shell mounds, tombs, pit houses, and chashi on the Okhotsk Sea coast and the Shiretoko Peninsula” and that “most of the archaeological sites were near Tokoro Town, which I visited in the fall of 1956, and I found the big shell mound here.”

The excavation started in Tokoro Town in 1957 and has continued as a research project of the Department of Archaeology at the University of Tokyo to the present day. In parallel with the excavation at Tokoro Town, excavations were carried out at Shari and Rausu towns on the Shiretoko Peninsula for three years, from 1958 to 1960. Komai led these excavations until 1959 but has not participated in the excavation since then.

As the research results in Tokoro accumulated, Komai hoped to build an “Ainu Research Center” as a site for research and study (Komai 1960 [written again in Komai 1977:190]), retiring from the University of Tokyo in 1965. It was in December of that year that the “Tokoro Town Museum” was established by the town, subsequently becoming the first building of the Tokoro Research Laboratory. Two years later, in 1967, the Faculty of Letters dispatched a research associate from the Department of Archaeology, and the facility known as the “Tokoro Field Laboratory” was established. This was the beginning of the Tokoro Research Laboratory that continues to this day.

(4) Chronological table of investigation in Hokkaido

With regard to Komai’s work mentioned above, the archaeological investigations carried out only in Hokkaido are as follows.

1947

September 27-October 16:
First investigation of the Moyoro Shell Mound at Abashiri City (2)
(Schedule unknown):
Observation of the Mikasayama (Osyoro) Stone Circle at Otaru City (formerly Shioya Village)

1948

September 18-October 10:
Second investigation of the Moyoro Shell Mound at Abashiri City

1949

October 3-10:
Investigation of the Jichin’yama Stone Circle at Otaru City (formerly Shioya Village)
October 9-18:
Investigation of the Higashi Kushiro Shell Mound at Kushiro City (3)
(Schedule unknown):
Observation of chashi sites at Kushiro City

1950

September 25-October 5:
Investigation of the Nishizakiyama Stone Circle (Area 1) at Yoichi Town (4)
October 6:
Observation of the Hokuei (Soga) Stone Circle at Niseko Town (formerly Karifuto Town) (5)

1951

September 18-23:
Investigation of the Hokuei (Soga) Stone Circle
September 24:
Investigation of the Takidai Stone Circle (Soga Takidai Site) at Niseko Town (formerly Karifuto Town)
September 26-29:
Investigation of the Nishizakiyama Nishi Stone Circle (Area 2) at Yoichi Town (excavation of stone circles No. 1 [suspended], No. 2, and No. 3)
September 30:
Preliminary investigation of the Otoe Stone Circle at Fukagawa City (formerly Otoe Village) (Otoe Village permitted excavation at this time)
October 4-12:
Third investigation of the Moyoro Shell Mound (6)
(Schedule unknown):
General survey of the Shiretoko Peninsula (7)
October 15-19:
Investigation of the Ojironai Shell Mound at Mori Town

1952

October 3-4:
Investigation of the Keisatsu Urayama Site at Yoichi Town
October 5-8:
Excavation of the Nishizakiyama Nishi Stone Circle (Area 2) (excavation of stone circle No. 1 restarted)
October 9-10?:
Field survey around the Nishizakiyama Site and investigation of the Nishizakiyama Minami Stone Circle (Area 3) at Yoichi Town (excavation of stone circles No. 1 and No. 2, excavation of stone circle No. 3 [suspended])
October 12-16:
Investigation of the Otoe Stone Circle (measuring survey, excavation of stone circles No. 3 and No. 5 [suspended], excavation and reconstruction of stone circle No. 2)
October 17:
Observation of the Kamui Kotan Stone Circle (Kamui Kotan 5 Site) at Asahikawa City (formerly Kamui Village) (photographing stone circle No. 1 [“1号石籬”] which Kono and Mori excavated (Kono and Mori 1952)).
October 20-final date unknown:
Investigation of the Ojironai Shell Mound

1953

October 5?-:
Investigation of the Nishizakiyama Minami Stone Circle (Area 3) (excavation of stone circle No.3 restarted) (8)
October 9-12:
Investigation of the Otoe Stone Circle (excavation of stone circles No. 7 and No. 9) (9)
After October 13?-20:
Investigation of the Ojironai Shell Mound

1955

May 16-18:
Investigation of the Otoe Stone Circle (excavation of stone circles No. 3 and No.10 and stone circle No. 5 restarted)

1956

May 21-28:
Investigation of the Otoe Stone Circle (excavation of stone circles No. 11, No. 12, and No. 13) (10)
Autumn:
Observation of the archaeological sites at Kitami City (formerly Tokoro Town) with Nobutake Onishi

1957

October 6-14:
Investigation of the Sakaeura Ⅰ Site at Kitami City (excavation of pit houses No. 1, No. 2, and No. 3)

1958

August 15-22:
Investigation of the Sakaeura Ⅱ Site at Kitami City (excavation of pit house No. 1)
August (detailed schedule unknown):
Supplementary investigation of the Ojironai Shell Mound
October 25-27:
Investigation of the Gattanko Shell Mound and Gattanko Chashi Site at Shari Town, inspection of pit houses at Utoro, Shari Town

1959

September 24-October 5:
Investigation of the Utoro Coast Dune Site (11)
October 4-11:
Investigation of the Gifu Ⅰ Site at Kitami City (excavation of pit houses No. 1 and No. 2)
Notes
  • 1 Komai classified “the stone circles or the standing stones, which are a degenerated form” into the following three types; “ストーン・サークル,” “環状列石墓,” and “立石遺構” (Komai 1973: 103). However, since there are some cases in which it is difficult to determine the classification, these archaeological sites are collectively called “stone circles” (環状列石) on this site.
  • 2 Since Komai wrote that he participated in this investigation from September 28 to October 18 (Komai 1977: 7), this site has followed the description of Komai ed. (1964).
  • 3 The schedule of the investigation of the Higashi Kushiro Shell Mound followed the description of Kono and Sawa (1962: 4). Although a part of the schedule of the Higashi Kushiro Shell Mound written in Kono and Sawa (1962) duplicates the schedule of the investigation of the Jichin’yama Site in this year (Komai 1959: 2), the details are unknown. However, as mentioned in the main text, while there are no records about this investigation in Komai’s chronological table (Komai [Fujie ed.] 1977), there is an outline in Komai (1952), where it is written that he not only excavated the Higashi Kushiro Shell Mound, but also observed some chashi sites around this archaeological site.
    Although it is written that Komai excavated the Moyoro Shell Mound following the investigation of “Osyoro” (it certainly points to Jichin’yama) in Komai’s chronological table (Komai [Fujie ed.] 1977: 8), there were no records about this, except for the description in Komai (Fujie ed. [1977: 8]). Consequently, the details are unknown. It is supposed that he may have mistaken the Higashi Kushiro Shell Mound for the Moyoro Shell Mound.
  • 4 Please refer to this page about the details of “the Nishizakiyama Site (Area 1),” “the Nishizaliyama Nishi Site (Area 2),” “the Nishizakiyama Minami Site (Area 3),” and these abbreviated names.
  • 5 According to Komai’s chronological table (Komai [Fujie ed.] 1977: 8), he carried out the excavation of the Moyoro Shell Mound until September 10, following the excavation of “the Yoichi Stone Circle.” On the other hand, there are no records of the investigation at the formerly Karifuto Town. There is no record except this description above, in which it is written that the investigation of the Moyoro Shell Mound was carried out in this year. The details are unknown.
  • 6 Although Komai (Fujie ed. [1977: 8]) wrote that he participated in the third investigation of the Moyoro Shell Mound from October 4-11, which follows the description in Komai (1964).
  • 7 Although Komai (Fujie ed. [1977]) did not mention the general survey of the Shiretoko Peninsula, according to Komai (1964: 99), he “carried out a general survey at Utoro, Rausu, and its surroundings based on Abashiri” in 1951. It is certain that this general survey was carried out both before and after the third investigation of the Moyoro Shell Mound.
  • 8 According to Komai’s chronological table (Komai [Fujied ed.] 1977: 9), he investigated Nishizakiyama, Shari Town, Otoe Village, and Ojironai from October 5 to 20, 1953. Since Komai (1973: 41) also says that he excavated stone circle No. 3 of the Nishizakiyama Minami Stone Circle (Area 3), it is certain that this investigation was carried out around October 5. The schedule of the investigation at Otoe Village is shown in note 9. However, the schedule of the investigation in Shari Town and the Ojironai Shell Mound are unknown. Komai wrote about the investigation in Shari Town that “it was the first time since 1951 that a general survey around Utoro and Rausu has been carried out” (Komai 1964: 99). There is a contradiction between these two descriptions. It is supposed that he may have mistaken the investigation in 1951 for the investigation in 1953.
  • 9 Although it was written that Komai excavated stone circles No. 3, No. 7, and No. 9 of the Otoe Stone Circle in October 9-12, 1953, according to Komai (1959: 4), the record on No. 3 in the excavation report said the investigation was suspended in 1952 and that he excavated the burial pit. This site follows the description of the latter regarding the schedule of the investigation of stone circle No. 3.
  • 10 According to Komai (1959: 4), Komai carried out this investigation from May 25-28, but both Komai (1973: 67) and Komai (Fujie ed. [1977: 10]) indicate that the schedule of this investigation was from May 21-28. This site follows the latter works.
  • 11 Part of the schedules of the investigation of the Utoro Coast Dune Site (Komai 1964) and the Gifu 1 Site (Komai 1963) overlap. The details are unknown.
References
  • The sentences and chronological tables above mainly refer to Onuki (2002), Komai (1959, 1973), Komai (1963, 1964), and Komai ([Fujie ed.] 1977). The list of references is here (page in Japanese).