Outline
One of the characteristics of Buddhist thought in modern Japan
is the attempt to rationalize and demythologize its theory. Specifically,
there is a tendency to be critical of esoteric teachings, to separate
"Buddhist" and "Shinto" elements, to deny the
validity of a Buddhism centered on funerary rites, and to establish
a "contemporary" Buddhism. Such a rationalization of ideas
on the surface (the "upper" structure) does not necessarily
mean that Buddhism as a whole has been modernized. It also means
that there are actual conditions hidden in the shadows (the "lower"
structure) that have become even further concealed. These conditions
include esoteric-magical elements, the mutual complementation of
"Buddhist" and "Shinto" elements, and the management
of the dead through Buddhist funerary rites. In other words, modern
Buddhism has sought to establish its universality through a modern
and rational theoretical framework, but has concealed the faith
of the people as it actually functions in society, and has failed
to deal directly with this theoretical problem. This concealment
is one reason that the relationship of Buddhism to imperial (Tenno)
nationalism has not been sufficiently confronted.
This problem, which was concealed and covered up in the Buddhist
realm, was confronted in terms of "Shinto" from the late
modern through the Meiji period. The Shinto nationalism of modern
"State Shinto" was not simply a matter of being imposed
from above. There was an indigenous "grass-roots nationalism"
that was swept up in the process. As for "emperor worship",
when one considers traditional worship of kami and the belief in
living kami, it is not surprising that there was little resistance
to the expansion of these ideas with the new introduction of the
emperor as an absolute-kami-cum-living-god. Again, if we consider
the case of Yasukuni Shrine, it must be admitted that the aspects
of funerary rites and management of the dead that had been concealed
by Buddhism were skillfully incorporated by Shinto, so that Shinto
successfully took over these aspects from Buddhism.
In my presentation I will examine, from a mostly Buddhist perspective,
the multi-layered structure of Buddhism/Shinto in modern Japan,
and also analyze future possibilities, in light of the changes in
the social structure of Japan and recent shifts in religious consciousness.
|